Book Review: Song of Silver, Flame Like Night
by: Amélie Wen Zhao
Lan, a song girl in a tea house, knows what it’s like to lose everything. She lost her mother, her home, her culture. When she meets Zen, she loses everything again. However, this time is different. Zen not only saves her, he introduces her to a world of magic and excitement. He might even be able to lead her to answers about her past.
Amélie Wen Zhao’s book Song of Silver, Flame Like Night is an epic adventure fantasy novel. It focuses on a girl, who goes by Lan, and she has a strange looking scar on her arm that appeared the day her mother died. One day, she finds herself being hunted by the man who killed her mom. She is saved by a Hin practitioner who promises to take her to his school to learn the art of magic. She vows to learn about her mother, find the reason she was killed, and to gain the strength to protect those around her. She never wants to lose another person again.
This book is not a casual read. Zhao drops her readers into the world of this book during a very complicated and political time. There are many events that must be explained to the reader in order to understand the world’s current political climate. This leads the opening of this story to be a bit dry and confusing at times. Zhao focuses on explaining how the Elantians are in power and are subjugating and assimilating the Hin people into their culture. The reader must focus on learning the world’s background in order to understand the story’s events and the characters’ thoughts and emotions.
Once the story starts moving along, the characters really start to become more of the focus on this book. Both Lan and Zen, the main characters of the novel, are strong deep characters. They both go through a lot of changes throughout their journey and experiences. I really enjoy how Zhao has written them both as complete opposites in their personalities. Lan is strong willed, casual, down to earth, and realistic in personality. Zen is much more proper, strait-laced, and scholarly. The two of them as a pair, create a really nice contrast to each other. There are many moments in the book where their contrasts balance each other out to cover each of their weaknesses and enhance their strengths. In fact, many of the characters in this novel help to enhance each other. Zhao created many interesting characters that come in and out of Zen and Lan’s adventures. Some help and some hinder, but all of them are well done and add to the story.
Zhao also did an excellent job creating the world this story is set in. It is obvious that she took her time to create a complex world with many nuances to it. This is shown in the complexity of the political situations as well as the cultural heritage the characters have. Throughout the story, we learn many different things about the Hin people as well as the subjugating Elantians. There are many interesting places Zen and Lan visit to provide depth to the world and believability to the setting. Even the fantasy elements add depth as magic and demons are introduced into the story. It is clear that Zhao took the time to craft this world and create a rich and powerful history to it.
I also appreciate the story itself since it has so many twists, turns, and surprises in it. This novel sets up the base of the world and its characters. Then, as the story continues further and further, many events change or complicate the story even more. There were many events that happened that I didn’t see coming. It has been a while since I read a book that surprised me as much as this one did. If you like books that have a lot of unexpected changes or that surprise you, then this one truly does subvert expectations.
On the other hand, there are a few downsides to this novel. To start with, this book is almost too detailed in the world building and magic development. The details and richness of the world is really great; however, it has moments when the story drags a bit from the detailed explanations. The most prominent moments are when Lan is learning about magic. Those who are teaching her explain how the magic works or why the magic works. The explanations are often really interesting, but they can also turn into very dry reading. It can be a very fine line when knowing how much detail to add to a story. Too little can make a story less enjoyable, but having too much can also slow down the story and make it less enjoyable. This particular novel is mostly balanced on how much detail to give and how much action to have. Yet, there are some moments where it becomes a bit boring and bogged down. The details were too complicated to explain without a full lecture.
The other main downside to the story is how long it is. The story is very interesting with a lot of mystery and new discoveries. The pacing of the novel is really good. However, the plot just kept going even after many events that seemed like a final climax. After each hurdle was overcome, the characters would find themselves in a new more complicated situation. This happened several times, so instead of building tension, it started to drag on more and more. Once the book is over, it is clear where Zhao wanted to end the book and where she saw the break in the story to be. For me, the story just seemed to keep going without a clearly defined goal or stopping place in sight. It would have been better to stop the book earlier and pick up with the conflict in the beginning of the next book.
Overall, I did enjoy this book. It is a denser read which was hard to push through at times, but I was fully interested in the plot line. I think this novel has many different things to offer many kinds of readers. If you like more complex, deep reads, this book would be perfect for you. I really enjoyed the asian influences and the uniqueness of the plot. I am not anxiously waiting for the next book, but I am looking forward to being able to find out what will come next once the second book is released.
Pros:
- Deep development of world history
- Deep development of magic
- Complex characters with lots of development
- Plenty of mysteries and surprises
Cons:
- Politics and world building can be dry and confusing
- Magic explanations are sometimes over done and becomes boring
- Starts to drag on at the end
Recommended for Readers Who Like:
- High Fantasy
- Third Person Point of View
- Asian Culture
- Lots of Magic and Adventure
- Complex World
- Serious Storylines
Book Details:
- Published: January 3, 2023
- Series: Song of the Last Kingdom
- Book Number: 1
- Pages: 467
- Publisher: Delacorte Press
If you want to see my rating system Click Here
Amélie Wen Zhao’s Website: Click Here
See my video review: Click Here